10 Best Dog Lotion For Dry Itchy Skin in 2026

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

The best dog lotion for dry itchy skin is Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream, a vet-strength hydrocortisone formula that stops itching without stinging or requiring pre-cleaning. For owners who want a lick-safe option, the Doc Itchy Itch Relief Cream works as both a spot treatment and full-body lotion. The Palmer’s Dog Lotion Spray offers a fragrance-free, easy-to-apply alternative for dogs with sensitive skin.

Dry, itchy skin in dogs has many causes, seasonal allergies, dry air, flea bites, or contact irritants, and each demands a different approach. A cream that works for a single hot spot may not cover a full-body issue, and a spray that soothes general dryness won’t stop severe inflammation. Matching the product to the specific problem is what actually helps your dog.

This guide is based on manufacturer specifications, expert recommendations from veterinary sources, and patterns in owner feedback across hundreds of reviews. We organized the 10 best dog lotions by their strengths so you can find the right format, ingredient profile, and potency for your dog’s particular itch.

Top 10 Dog Lotions For Dry Itchy Skin in the Market

Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided "as is" and is subject to change or removal at any time.

The Best Dog Lotions For Dry Itchy Skin, Reviewed

#1Best Overall

Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream

Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream
Active Ingredient1% Hydrocortisone
Size1 oz
ApplicationNo pre-cleaning needed
SafetySafe if licked after application
Use ForFace, paws, body folds
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Veterinarian-strength hydrocortisone for itch relief
  • No-sting formula requires no pre-cleaning
  • Safe if licked after application
  • Gentle enough for face, paws, and folds

Trade-offs

  • 1 oz tube is small for large dogs or widespread issues
  • Contains hydrocortisone, unsuitable for long-term daily use

With 1% hydrocortisone in a veterinarian-strength formula, this cream provides gentle, soothing relief from skin irritations like itchy skin, hot spots, and dermatitis. The no-sting, no-pre-cleaning design means you can apply it straight to irritated spots on the face, paws, or body folds without causing extra discomfort, and it’s safe if your dog licks the area afterward. That combination of potency and practical ease makes it a reliable option for owners who want effective relief without a complicated routine.

For a dog with a single hot spot or a patch of facial itch, the 1% hydrocortisone in this cream delivers vet-strength relief without the sting of many medicated ointments. The no-sting formula means you don’t have to scrub the area first, which makes application far less stressful for a sore pet. Just squeeze a bit from the 1 oz tube and dab it on, no pre-cleaning needed, so it’s quick and gentle.

Best for: Dog owners dealing with localized hot spots or facial itch who want a vet-strength cream that applies without stinging or pre-cleaning

Product photos

#2Best Lick-Safe Soother

Doc Itchy Itch Relief Cream

Doc Itchy Itch Relief Cream
Size10 oz
Key IngredientsColloidal Oatmeal & Zinc
ApplicationFull body or hot spot cream
Lick-SafeYes
Made InUSA
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Lick-safe formula for worry-free use
  • 2-in-1: hot spot cream or full-body lotion
  • Colloidal oatmeal calms inflamed skin
  • Zinc supports healing and barrier function

Trade-offs

  • Full-body use requires rinse after application
  • Results need consistent use over 1-2 weeks
  • Not a hydrocortisone cream for severe inflammation

A 10-ounce tub of colloidal oatmeal and zinc cream that’s safe if your dog licks it after applying, that’s the whole point of the ‘Lick-Safe Soother’ badge. You can use it as a targeted hot spot cream (let it absorb for five minutes) or spread it as a lightweight full-body lotion for dry, itchy skin. The zinc helps support healing of broken skin, while the oatmeal calms redness and flaking. It’s made in the USA with vet-approved, non-toxic ingredients, so you’re not worrying about harsh chemicals every time your dog decides to investigate the spot you just treated. This is the pick for owners whose dogs won’t leave treated areas alone, because the formula is designed to be safe if licked, and you can reapply every 12 to 24 hours as needed.

For full-body use, you massage Doc Itchy Itch Relief Cream in, rinse lightly, and repeat every 3-7 days for up to two weeks to see improvement. That’s more steps than a spray like Palmer’s Dog Lotion Spray, which you just spray on. But Doc Itchy offers a 10-ounce tub, so you get more volume than Zymox’s 1-ounce tube, and it’s safe if licked, which Palmer’s doesn’t claim. If your dog has a single hot spot, Zymox has 1% hydrocortisone, but it’s not labeled lick-safe and comes in a smaller size. Doc Itchy gives you flexibility for both spot and full-body care, as long as you follow the rinse-and-repeat routine.

Best for: Dog owners who need a lick-safe, two-in-one cream for both hot spots and full-body dry skin, and don't mind a rinse step for full-body use. Not ideal for those wanting a no-rinse spray or immediate steroid-level itch relief.

Product photos

#3Best Spray-On Lotion

Palmer's Dog Lotion Spray

Palmer's Dog Lotion Spray
FormPump spray lotion
Size8 fl oz (237 mL)
Key IngredientsCocoa butter, vitamin E, shea butter, sunflower seed oil
FragranceFragrance free
Target UseDry, allergy-prone sensitive skin
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Fragrance free and paraben free
  • Pump spray bottle for easy application
  • Contains cocoa butter, shea butter, and vitamin E
  • Fast itch relief for dry skin

Trade-offs

  • Not a cream or balm for spot treatments
  • Contains phenoxyethanol, a preservative some owners avoid

An 8 fl oz (237 mL) pump spray bottle delivers a lotion that targets dry, allergy-prone sensitive skin directly. The formula uses cocoa butter, shea butter, sunflower seed oil, and vitamin E, all moisturizers that soothe itch without added fragrance or parabens. That makes this a practical everyday option for dogs who need regular relief and don’t tolerate scented products well.

Palmer’s Dog Lotion Spray comes in a pump spray bottle, so you can cover your dog’s body quickly without having to rub in a thick cream. The cocoa butter formula with vitamin E and shea butter is designed for dogs with allergy-prone sensitive skin, giving direct relief from dryness and itchy skin almost immediately. It’s fragrance free and paraben free, making it a gentle option for everyday use.

Best for: Dog owners looking for a fragrance-free, spray-on lotion to soothe dry, itchy skin on dogs with allergy-prone sensitive skin. Not ideal for dogs that need a very concentrated treatment on a single small spot.

Product photos

#4Best Easy-Apply Stick

Natural Dog Company Skin Soother Balm

Natural Dog Company Skin Soother Balm
Form2 oz stick
Key IngredientsCoconut oil, cocoa butter, chamomile
ApplicationTwist-up stick, direct apply
Target UseElbows, dry patches, belly
ScentBotanical (not fragrance-free)
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Twist-up stick for mess-free application
  • Contains coconut oil and botanical ingredients
  • Targets rough elbows and dry patches
  • Works for seasonal winter dryness

Trade-offs

  • Requires two to three daily applications
  • Has a noticeable botanical scent, not fragrance-free

The twist-up stick lets you apply the balm directly to rough elbows or dry patches without having to scoop it out of a tin. So there is no need to get your fingers into a jar. It is designed for targeted care rather than full-body coverage, which makes sense for dogs that only need extra moisture on specific spots. The coconut oil, cocoa butter, and chamomile formula helps condition flaky skin during winter or seasonal changes, and the compact stick fits easily into a grooming kit or pocket for quick use after walks.

The balm has a botanical scent from ingredients like lavender and myrrh, so it is not fragrance-free. It is designed for targeted application on specific dry areas rather than full-body coverage, so if your dog has widespread dry skin, a liquid lotion may be more suitable. For focused care on elbows, bellies, and rough patches, the stick’s convenience and ingredient list make it a practical everyday option.

Best for: Dog owners who want a no-mess, targeted balm for dry elbows and patches. Not ideal for dogs needing full-body moisture or those sensitive to botanical scents.

Product photos

#5Best Fast-Acting Relief

Paw Science Anti-Itch Hydrocortisone Lotion

Paw Science Anti-Itch Hydrocortisone Lotion
Active Ingredient1% Hydrocortisone
Key AdditiveAloe Vera
Suitable ForDogs & Cats
Made InUSA (FDA-registered facility)
Application AreasFace folds, paws, ears, elbows
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Vet-strength hydrocortisone for fast relief
  • Safe for sensitive areas like face folds
  • Non-greasy, quick-absorbing lotion
  • Soothes hot spots, flea bites, and dermatitis

Trade-offs

  • Not a spray, requires manual application
  • Not ideal for pets with severe skin infections

Vet-strength hydrocortisone with aloe vera quickly soothes hot spots, allergy itching, flea bites, dermatitis, eczema, and everyday skin irritations. The gentle, no-sting formula is safe for sensitive areas like face folds, skin folds, paws, underarms, groin, outer ears, and elbows on both dogs and cats. This lightweight, non-greasy lotion absorbs faster than a spray and stays in place, so it won’t drip off or require reapplication. It’s made in an FDA-registered facility in the USA.

Because it’s a lotion, you apply it directly to the irritated spot, ideal for a single hot spot but less practical if your pet has itching over a large area. Compared to Palmer’s Dog Lotion Spray, which is meant for dry, allergy-prone sensitive skin, this lotion delivers a medicated active ingredient for stubborn, localized trouble spots. For fast-acting relief on one or two patches, this lotion is the better choice.

Best for: Pet owners with localized hot spots or allergy-related itching who need fast, targeted relief. Not ideal for covering large body areas or for pets with skin that reacts to hydrocortisone.

Product photos

#6Best Non-Stinging Gel

vetr Skin Relief Hydrocortisone Gel

vetr Skin Relief Hydrocortisone Gel
Active Ingredient1% Hydrocortisone
FormGel
Size4 oz (120 mL)
ScentFragrance-free
OriginVet-formulated in USA
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Non-stinging, quick-absorbing gel
  • Fragrance-free for sensitive noses
  • 1% hydrocortisone targets hot spots
  • Mess-free direct application

Trade-offs

  • For occasional use, not chronic conditions
  • Consult vet before prolonged application
  • Only 4 oz tube for multiple applications

A 1% hydrocortisone gel that doesn’t sting on application means your dog won’t flinch away when you touch a hot spot or bug bite. This vet-formulated, fragrance-free formula absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy mess on fur or furniture. It’s designed for occasional flare-ups like insect bites or irritated patches, not for managing ongoing skin conditions. For a dog that needs targeted relief, this gel provides a practical option.

The trade-off is its purpose: this is a spot-treatment gel for acute issues, not a daily moisturizer for chronic dry skin. If your dog has widespread or persistent itching, a different product might be more suitable. But for a single irritated spot that needs relief, the vetr gel’s non-stinging formula and easy application make it a practical choice. Just remember to check with your vet if you need to use it more than a few days.

Best for: Dog owners who need a quick, no-fuss gel for occasional hot spots or bug bites that won't make their pet recoil. Not ideal for managing chronic, widespread dry skin or as a daily moisturizer.

Product photos

#7Best Natural Ingredients

ResQ Organics Hot Spot Treatment

ResQ Organics Hot Spot Treatment
Size4 oz
Key IngredientsManuka Honey, Aloe Vera, Vitamin E
Formula TypeNo-sting, steroid-free, fragrance-free
ApplicationQuick-absorbing ointment
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • No-sting formula for irritated skin
  • Made with Manuka Honey and Aloe Vera
  • Safe if licked, food-grade ingredients
  • Works for dogs, cats, and horses

Trade-offs

  • Not a hydrocortisone treatment for severe inflammation
  • Contains coconut oil, which some dogs avoid

The 4-ounce tub of ResQ Organics Hot Spot Treatment packs Manuka Honey, Aloe Vera, and Vitamin E into a no-sting, steroid-free ointment that absorbs quickly. So you’re not waiting around for it to dry before your dog can move. This makes it a good option if your dog has raw, irritated skin and you want something gentle enough that it won’t cause more pain on contact. The food-grade ingredients also mean you don’t have to panic if they lick it off, which is a real relief when dealing with a persistent hotspot.

The trade-off is that this is not a hydrocortisone cream. So if your dog’s itching is driven by heavy inflammation, you might get faster relief from something like Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream with 1% hydrocortisone. But for everyday dry, itchy skin, minor wounds, or paw balm duty, ResQ Organics covers a lot of ground without the sting or steroids. It’s a versatile, natural-first option that works across species, which is handy if you’ve got both a dog and a cat with skin issues.

Best for: Dog owners who want a gentle, natural, multi-purpose ointment for dry itchy skin and minor wounds. Not ideal for dogs with severe inflammatory itching that requires a steroid-based treatment.

Product photos

#8Best Pure Aloe Formula

Raslok Aloe Vera Gel for Dogs

Raslok Aloe Vera Gel for Dogs
Ingredients100% natural Aloe Vera
Size220gm (7.7oz)
Free FromParaben, Alcohol, Fragrance, Color
UseExternal use only
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • 100% natural Aloe Vera formula
  • Free from parabens, alcohol, fragrance, color
  • Soothes hot spots and dry itchy skin
  • Promotes healing of cuts and scrapes

Trade-offs

  • Avoid contact with eyes, mouth, and open wounds
  • Cannot be used with other topical treatments without vet approval

A 100% natural Aloe Vera formula means you’re putting nothing but pure plant gel on your dog’s irritated skin, no parabens, alcohol, fragrance, or color to sting or cause more trouble. That makes it a smart pick for dogs with sensitive skin or allergies who react to the extras in other lotions. It’s designed to tackle hot spots, dry patches, and minor cuts, so it covers the common reasons a dog starts scratching in the first place. If you want something that hydrates without layering on chemicals, this gel keeps it simple and effective.

That limits how you can combine it with, say, a hydrocortisone cream like Zymox Veterinarian Strength if the itching is severe. It also needs to stay away from eyes, mouth, and open wounds, so you’ll have to apply it carefully on a squirmy dog. For everyday dry skin relief with a clean ingredient list, it’s hard to beat, just don’t expect it to work as a multi-treatment fix.

Best for: Dog owners who want a pure, fragrance-free aloe gel for soothing dry, itchy skin and minor irritations without added chemicals. Not ideal for dogs needing medicated treatment or for use alongside other topical products.

Product photos

#9Best Multi-Ingredient Cream

Tetesol Dog Moisturiser Cream

Tetesol Dog Moisturiser Cream
Key Ingredients12 plant-based actives
Size100g
Suitable ForDogs, cats, puppies 12 weeks+
ApplicationNon-greasy, vacuum pump with silicone tip
Skin ConcernsItching, dryness, rashes, hot spots, sores
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • 12 plant-based actives soothe multiple skin issues
  • Colloidal oatmeal, cucumber, calendula for fast relief
  • Non-greasy formula with precise silicone tip applicator
  • Safe for dogs, cats, and puppies over 12 weeks

Trade-offs

  • Not a hydrocortisone-based treatment for severe inflammation

A formula packed with 12 plant-based actives means this cream tackles more than just dry, itchy skin, it addresses rashes, hot spots, sores, and even paw fold irritation all at once. That makes it a practical choice if your dog has multiple trouble areas or you want one product that covers a lot of ground without reaching for separate treatments. The colloidal oatmeal, cucumber extract, and calendula work fast to calm the itch-scratch cycle, so your dog gets visible relief sooner rather than later. And the vacuum pump with a soft silicone tip makes application clean and precise, which matters when you’re dabbing cream onto a sore spot without making a mess.

The 100g size is compact enough for a glove box or travel bag, but on a large breed with widespread skin issues you might reorder more often than with a bigger tub. Compared to Doc Itchy’s 10 oz cream, Tetesol has less volume and no hydrocortisone, so it’s not meant for severe inflammation, for that, Zymox with 1% hydrocortisone would be the choice. For everyday relief from itching, dryness, and hot spots using plant-based ingredients and a non-greasy pump, this cream covers a lot of ground.

Best for: Dog owners looking for a multi-ingredient, non-greasy cream that soothes itching, dryness, and hot spots with plant-based actives and precise application. Not ideal for those needing a large-volume or hydrocortisone-based treatment for severe skin conditions.

Product photos

#10Best Natural Essential Oil Blend

Jax N Daisy Don’t Let Your Dog Itch Lotion

Jax N Daisy Don’t Let Your Dog Itch Lotion
Size16 oz
Key IngredientsLavender, Aloe Vera, Witch Hazel
Safe ForDogs & Cats, 8 weeks+
ApplicationNo rinsing required
Check Latest Price →

What We Like

  • Natural essential oil blend
  • Safe for dogs and cats
  • No rinsing needed after application
  • Works on all coat types

Trade-offs

  • Not suitable for pets under 8 weeks of age.

A 16-ounce bottle of this lotion uses a proprietary blend of lavender, aloe vera, and witch hazel to tackle dry, itchy skin without harsh chemicals. That means you can apply it generously over hot spots or general irritation, and because it requires no rinsing, you’re done in seconds. It’s a straightforward option for owners who want a plant-based approach that works on both dogs and cats, regardless of coat type, from puppies eight weeks old onward.

Compared to the Zymox cream with hydrocortisone, this lotion relies entirely on essential oils for relief, so if your dog has severe inflammation, the medicated route may be more direct. For everyday soothing without chemicals, though, it’s a practical pick that pairs with the brand’s shampoo for a consistent routine.

Best for: Owners seeking a natural, essential-oil-based lotion for mild to moderate dry skin and hot spots on dogs or cats. Not ideal for pets with severe inflammation or owners who prefer unscented products.

How We Evaluated Dog Lotions For Dry Itchy Skin

We started by reviewing the active ingredients in each product, hydrocortisone levels, natural soothers like colloidal oatmeal and aloe vera, and base components that affect absorption and safety. Manufacturer documentation told us whether a formula was lick-safe, required rinsing, or needed a vet’s approval before use on certain areas.

Three criteria mattered most. First, application format: creams, sprays, sticks, and gels each suit different coat types and dog temperaments. Second, ingredient safety for the intended use site, some products are fine for paws but not the face, and others are gentle enough for ear folds. Third, the severity of itch each product is designed to handle: a mild daily moisturizer won’t stop a hot spot, and a steroid cream shouldn’t be used for simple dry skin.

A research-based evaluation has limits. Individual reactions vary widely. Owner feedback patterns give a strong sense of what works for most dogs, but your pet’s specific allergy or skin condition may require a veterinarian’s diagnosis before any topical treatment.

What To Look For In Dog Lotions For Dry Itchy Skin

Choosing the right lotion means matching the product format, active ingredient, and safety profile to your dog’s specific itch pattern and location. The wrong format can make application a battle, and the wrong ingredient can delay healing.

Look for a lotion that matches your dog’s itch location (face, paws, or body), severity (mild dryness versus hot spots), and your own tolerance for application steps like rinsing or avoiding licking.

Active Ingredients and Potency

Hydrocortisone is the gold standard for inflammatory itching, hot spots, flea allergy dermatitis, and contact reactions. Vet-strength formulas like the 1% hydrocortisone in Zymox and Paw Science provide fast relief for localized issues. For dogs that need daily maintenance without steroids, look for colloidal oatmeal, aloe vera, shea butter, or coconut oil, which moisturize and calm without suppressing inflammation. Zinc supports barrier repair in lick-safe formulas like Doc Itchy.

Application Format and Dog Temperament

Creams and balms work best for spot treatments on bare skin or short-coated areas, but they require you to hold still for application. Sprays like Palmer’s cover large areas fast, ideal for dogs that won’t tolerate being touched on a sore spot. Sticks like the Natural Dog Company Skin Soother Balm let you apply without getting product on your hands, which helps when treating facial areas or paws. Gels absorb quickly and don’t drip, making them a good choice for wriggly dogs.

Safety and Lick Tolerance

Some dogs will lick any topical product off immediately. If yours is one of them, a lick-safe formula like Doc Itchy or ResQ Organics is necessary. Other products contain hydrocortisone or preservatives that are not safe to ingest in quantity. Check whether the product requires rinsing after full-body use. Doc Itchy does, while most spot treatments do not. For facial application, avoid products with alcohol, fragrances, or essential oils that could sting or irritate eyes and nostrils.

  • Confirm the product is labeled safe for the body part you’re treating (face, paws, ears)
  • Check whether the formula requires rinsing after a set time
  • Read the ingredient list for allergens your dog has reacted to before
  • Start with a small patch test on a non-sensitive area
  • Ask your vet before using hydrocortisone on a dog with a suspected skin infection

If your dog is already scratching raw skin, a soothing cream with colloidal oatmeal or aloe can provide immediate comfort while you address the underlying cause.

Dog Lotions For Dry Itchy Skin Compared

The table below compares all 10 dog lotions for dry itchy skin by their key features, so you can see at a glance which format and ingredient profile fits your dog’s needs.

ProductKey IngredientsSizeApplication
Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream1% Hydrocortisone1 ozNo pre-cleaning needed
Doc Itchy Itch Relief CreamColloidal Oatmeal & Zinc10 ozFull body or hot spot cream
Palmer's Dog Lotion SprayCocoa butter, vitamin E, shea butter, sunflower seed oil8 fl oz (237 mL)Pump spray lotion
Natural Dog Company Skin Soother BalmCoconut oil, cocoa butter, chamomile2 oz stickTwist-up stick, direct apply
Paw Science Anti-Itch Hydrocortisone Lotion1% HydrocortisoneN/AN/A
vetr Skin Relief Hydrocortisone Gel1% Hydrocortisone4 oz (120mL)Direct application to affected areas
ResQ Organics Hot Spot TreatmentManuka Honey, Aloe Vera, Vitamin E4 ozQuick-absorbing ointment
Raslok Aloe Vera Gel for Dogs100% natural Aloe Vera220gm (7.7oz)External use only
Tetesol Dog Moisturiser Cream12 plant-based actives100gNon-greasy, vacuum pump with silicone tip
Jax N Daisy Don’t Let Your Dog Itch LotionLavender, Aloe Vera, Witch Hazel16 ozNo rinsing required

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use human lotion on my dog’s dry skin?

No. Human lotions often contain ingredients like artificial fragrances, alcohols, and preservatives that can irritate a dog’s skin or cause toxicity if licked. Dog-specific formulas are pH-balanced for canine skin and use safe active ingredients like colloidal oatmeal or hydrocortisone at appropriate concentrations.

How often should I apply dog lotion for dry itchy skin?

Frequency depends on the product and the severity of the dryness. Most spot-treatment creams recommend two to three applications daily for the first few days, then as needed. Spray-on lotions can be used more frequently since they are lighter. Always follow the specific product’s instructions, and stop use if the skin worsens or does not improve within a week.

Is hydrocortisone cream safe for dogs?

Yes, when used correctly. Over-the-counter 1% hydrocortisone creams are safe for short-term use on localized hot spots, bug bites, and allergic reactions. They should not be used on open wounds, around the eyes, or for more than seven consecutive days without a veterinarian’s guidance. Long-term steroid use can thin the skin and delay healing.

What natural ingredients soothe dry itchy skin on dogs?

Colloidal oatmeal, aloe vera, coconut oil, shea butter, and calendula are common natural soothers. Oatmeal reduces inflammation and forms a protective barrier, while aloe cools and hydrates. Manuka honey, found in ResQ Organics, has antibacterial properties. These ingredients work best for mild to moderate dryness, not for severe inflammatory itching that requires a steroid.

Should I bathe my dog before applying lotion?

For spot treatments, no, most products like Zymox work without pre-cleaning. For full-body lotions, a bath with a gentle shampoo for dry skin can remove allergens and debris, allowing the lotion to absorb better. Dry your dog thoroughly before applying any topical product, as moisture trapped under the lotion can worsen skin irritation.

The Bottom Line

The Zymox Veterinarian Strength Topical Cream is the best overall choice for most dogs with localized hot spots or facial itch. Its no-sting, no-pre-clean formula makes application simple even on sensitive areas, and the vet-strength hydrocortisone delivers relief fast. It is the pick for owners who want a proven active ingredient without a complicated routine.

If your dog licks everything off immediately, the Doc Itchy Itch Relief Cream is the right alternative, it is lick-safe and works as both a spot treatment and a full-body lotion. For dogs with general dry skin rather than hot spots, the Palmer’s Dog Lotion Spray covers large areas without fragrance or fuss. Budget-minded owners should look at the Raslok Aloe Vera Gel, which uses a single pure ingredient at an affordable price point.

The single most important factor is matching the product to the itch. A steroid cream for mild dryness is overkill, and a natural balm for a hot spot is underkill. Know what you are treating before you buy, and when in doubt, ask your vet.